Articles in this section are of general information and in every situation are subject to the application and interpretation of a law, rule or factual situation that may differ. Consult us for any specific question.

No one can take advantage of their own fault

Business Law, Civil Law, Civil Liability

This is an old principle dating back to the beginning of time that can be applied to an incalculable number of situations. This is only common sense: no one can take advantage of their own fault. This is the duty of care that is required of all of us, at all times.

For example, an intoxicated person who falls off their bike cannot blame the barkeeper or brewer for the physical injury they have suffered! Similarly, someone who falls on the sidewalk while wearing stilettos may be partly responsible for their fate, even if the municipality was negligent in the maintenance. In this last example, if the victim has committed a fault, there may be a sharing of responsibility, at the discretion of the court, so that the municipality should bear only part of the damage caused.

In contractual matters, this concept is also applicable. Whoever asks for the cancellation of a contract because of an error may sometimes be challenged that this is an inexcusable error. It is also for this reason that there is no possible recourse in case of injury, save for some exceptions. That is to say that you cannot request the cancellation of a contract under the pretext that you have only paid too much. A diligent person must shop around!

In case of a dispute, your behaviour will be scrutinized and should there be a breach of your duty of care, you could suffer the consequences. Be careful and diligent at all times!

You might also be interested in

Deux mains qui tendent un élastique

Abuse of process : where do we draw the line?

A litigator's main job is to follow the provisions of the Civil Code of Quebec in managing his or her litigation files, and thus to draft and present proceedings before the courts. However, some people, and even some lawyers, make improper use of these procedures....